|
TikiWiki Assistant Thank you for installing TikiWiki!
Click the :: options in the Menu for more options. Please, also see TikiMovies for more setup details. |
Ken Comer, President 2009-2012 →
Transitive Trust
The idea of a "Transitive Trust" legislation/representation system is simply this: you pick someone you trust (who picks someone s/he trusts {repeat as necessary}) who then wields your vote. Your vote is actually a conglomeration of votes on different subjects, each of which may be represented by a different group or individual. You might recognize the word, "transitive", from your old elementary math book when it talked about the "transitive quality of equality" saying "if a = b and b = c, then a = c". This is like that: if you trust someone with your vote and they trust someone else, it is assumed that you trust the person that they trust. Please bear in mind that the actual mechanics are in the early stage of design and that some of the process is streamlined for the purpose of simplifying the example. Let's pick a sample subject, "high speed train route from Raleigh, NC to Seattle, WA" and three categories from the vote-topic list that might be associated with it: "roads, bridges and highways", "ecology", and "business". The Topic List? Review Board would have been responsible for determining which topics were related to the subject "high speed trains" and what the relevant proportion each of the topics represent. Let's assume that they decided like this:
For issues related to "ecology and the environment, let's assume you opted to let Joe keep up with that issue for you, that Joe represents a number of people, and that Joe delegates 45% of his votes to the National Wildlife Conservatory, 35% to Green Peas, and 20% to Sue. Sue is on vacation this week, so she delegates all her votes--hers plus those that have been delegated to her--to the National Wildlife Conservatory. Sue would have informed those people whose proxies she held that she was on vacation, and it would be up to the people whose proxies she carries to inform people down the line (i.e., Joe would decide whether or not to keep you posted on this small shift in policy for your vote under the "ecology and environment" topic). In your case, that would be Joe and, as Sue was delegating her vote to an organization he trusts, he decided not to bother you. To keep things as simple as we can after mucking things up with the environment topic, let us assume that you have assigned the "roads, bridges and highways" to the Grand Old Party. Here's how your vote relates to this "high speed train" issue:
Let's assume that they came up with only a single proposal and all you are doing is saying 'yea' or 'nay'. Let's further assume that all of your topic-delegated votes elected for 'nay'. Perhaps the route suggested had a stop in your city, but it went through a wetlands area that ecology groups wanted to preserve and the GOP had decided against all railroad projects as a matter of policy. Here is how your vote would be tallied:
In practice, there would be safety measures that would come into play. If you had a "vote e-warning" option set, you would get the calculation of every vote e-mailed to you 48 hours before it took effect, so you could yank your vote back from the people you trusted (and the people they trusted) either on a permanent basis or just for this particular issue. Joe might forward information from Green Peas telling you about how this wetlands area was vital to the economy of Swamptown where you own a piece of property used as a time-share for eco-tourists. For a time, votes could be shuffled and negotiated. There would likely be several proposals for this issue, and you (and the delegates who have your proxy) would designate your/their order of preference. Full disclosure on how your vote was being employed on this single issue might take several pages to describe. This is why you would probably choose to delegate most or all of your vote to professionals or to organizations that you trust: being a legislator can be a full-time job. The basic process would go roughly as follows (there is also a Detailed Process Walk-Through):
Created by: kencomer last modification: Wednesday 11 of July, 2007 [19:40:46 UTC] by kencomer |
Login |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||